Friday 25 September 2015

Book Review: The Fire Sermon by Francesca Haig


There’s a chance that many readers will pass over The Fire Sermon, thinking that their appetites for post-apocalyptic YA novels with kick-ass female protagonists has been satiated. Yet it would truly be a mistake to miss out on this particular specimen of the genre.

The novel is set in a world rebuilt four-hundred years after a nuclear destruction of some sort rendered the entire landscape of the planet barren. The ecological hardships have, of course, also brought with them social turmoil. If it weren’t difficult enough to rebuild society after such a wipe-out, the blast has also altered human DNA, so that all humans are now born as part of a pair, twins, who are labelled Alfas and Omegas, and segregated accordingly. One twin, the Omega, often has a physical defect, while their Alpha twin is perfectly formed. They may be separated in early childhood, but they are forever connected in death – for if one dies, the other dies as well. This creates obvious complications in a society that seeks to segregate the two groups.

This premise was enough to pique my interest, but what Haig does with it, kept me going with the book. Beneath the post-apocalyptic adventure there is a persistent vein of psychological exploration – Zach, one of the main antagonists, is especially probed to discover what drives his actions. This renders him much more interesting than the often two-dimensional villains who cherish simple grievances and often don’t have consistent or clear motivations for their actions. The novel also extensively explores the effects of solitude and solitary confinement on the psyche, through the characters Cass and Kip, which also results in interesting revelations.

Through the character of Piper, the novel also examines the difficulties of leadership and sacrifice for the greater good. Piper sheds light on the very real issues with an idealistic view of this fractured world; Cass may harbor hopes of protecting all the innocents of her world, but it seems she has a difficult lesson coming her way. Many novels would paint the pragmatic strategist character as ultimately lacking in moral fiber, but at the end of the book, it seems that Haig wants to remind us that nothing is quite so black and white.

Although I greatly enjoyed it, all the philosophical and psychological exploration in the novel does detract somewhat from the action. The plotting of the story is quite simple: continual pursuit and travel through this destructed world in the first half, and little respite until the second part, in which our heroes take off on a quest of their own. It’s not the twists and turns of the plot, or the revelations (which most readers I’m sure could see a mile off even before Cass used her seer powers), or the fast-paced adventure that renders this book a great read, but rather the very real emotional, psychological, and moral explorations demanded in such a world.

You may feel that the market is over-saturated with post-apocalyptic YA novels with strong female leads, but Francesca Haig’s The Fire Sermon is still worth a read, as it offers a completely different world with its own set of rules, and a different style and perspective than that of others in this genre.

You can buy the book here.

Check out other reviews of the book on Good Reads.