Friday 22 August 2014

The Best Harry Potter Book



The other day, as we were out on the town with a couple of friends, the conversation inevitably turned to Harry Potter (inevitable mostly because I was there). A girl I had recently met stated with confident simplicity that the third book was the worst, and the second was the best. Normally, I try to accommodate other people’s opinions, but this statement literally left my mouth open. The Prisoner of Azkaban has always been my absolute favorite and I never even considered that there could be a person on the planet who would place it at the bottom of their list. I mean, Deathly Hallows? Sure, some people might be missing the Hogwarts scene. Chamber of Secrets? Definitely possible, I mean it did introduce some of the most annoying characters of the series (Colin Creevwy, Moaning Myrtle, Gilderoy Lockhart etc.). But I do love all of the books, so rather than pick faults with the above-mentioned; I’d like to defend my choice.

Here is why Harry Potter and The Prisoner of Azkaban is the best book in the Harry Potter series:





1.    The idea of the Animagi is first introduced in this book, which is one of the coolest things a witch or wizard can do in the Harry Potter universe. My only regret is that Harry and the gang didn’t embark on the difficult journey of becoming shape shifters themselves. Yet another reason why Harry’s parents deserve a spin-off.

2.     Not all the good things about HP3 are jolly and warm, some plot elements are horrible, but in a good way. Dementors first appear on the Hogwarts Express at the beginning of the book, in one of the most chilling and exciting scenes of all the books. The concept of Dementors is basically a great metaphor for life. When life/people/scary hooded figures, suck the life and happiness out of you, recover with chocolate and strike back with happy thoughts!

3.     Dementors and Patronuses go hand in hand, and with the latter Harry is finally shown to have a skill that is above average. Sure, Harry as a character is intentionally mediocre, and it is never stated that he himself possesses any extraordinary talent that would equip him for his struggle against Voldemort. Yet as a reader we like to think of the hero as, well, a hero. Harry’s kick-ass Patronus charm shows us that he’s no ordinary wizard.
­*Added tearjerking factor: Harry’s Patronus takes the form of a stag, his father’s Animagus. Sigh.

4.     Throughout the series, Harry has several father figures to guide him and give him some much-needed parental affection, yet arguably the most important of these figures is Sirius Black, around whom this book mostly revolves. As Harry’s godfather, and James Potter’s best friend, they provide each other with some comfort in their loss. The revelation of this link to his parents is one of the best things about the third installment.  Not to mention the fact that Sirius is pretty badass, riding around on his flying motorcycle, escaping from Azkaban, turning into a big scary dog whenever he pleases…

5.     Leading up to the discovery of his godfather’s true nature, Harry has another male mentor to guide him through this difficult year: Remus Lupin. Calm, kind and wise, yet approachable (apart from those unfortunate moments of werewolfiness), Lupin is arguably an even better father figure for Harry than Sirius or Dumbledore. But Lupin is an interesting character on his own, struggling to hide his “sickness” and lead a normal life. He’s also the only competent Defense Against the Dark Arts teacher Hogwarts ever saw, and a relief after the mess that was Gilderoy Lockhart.

6.     For readers who revel in the smallest details of life as a wizard in the Harry Potter universe, discovering Hogsmeade in the third book is a real treat. It is said to be the only muggle-free town in England, and is full of amazing places that we would love to visit, like The Three Broomsticks, Zonko’s, Honeydukes and even the Shrieking Shack,

7.     Hogmseade is also the first place we encounter the delicious (albeit fictional) drink butterbeer! Warm, frothy, sweet and likely containing a bit of alcohol, it sounds like the perfect antidote to a bitter cold winter day.

8.     Thanks to Fred and George’s kind heart, and the fact that Harry is initially banned from visiting Hogsmeade, the Marauder’s Map is introduced in this installment. Thankfully the books do not subsequently explore Harry’s slightly creepy tendency to check when Cho Chang goes to the bathroom and whatnot. Instead, it becomes a magical link to his father’s gang, often providing invaluable information and comic relief at the same time.

9.     It is the only book in the series that does not feature supervillain Voldemort. Now you may be asking yourself, why is this a good thing? Well, we all know that the series moves towards an ultimate resolution between Harry and Voldemort a.k.a. Good and Evil, but sometimes this gives the books a kind of pressure. You know that the book will end with some kind of confrontation with He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named, and this can become predictable. In the third book, this dynamic is switched up, and instead it revolves around the ambiguous nature of good and evil. It begins to question the events surrounding Voldemort’s fall, as well as some other aspects of the seemingly perfect wizarding society.

+ 1. The introduction of Professor Trewlaney, who seems like a useless nuisance most of the time, yet the character really comes into her own in Emma Thompson’s hilarious rendition. One of the very few instances when the movie enhances the book.

+ 2. This is a reinforcement of my opinion rather than a reason, but. J.K. Rowling has stated: “Out of the five books I've published [so far], writing Azkaban was the easiest, and in some ways I think that shows.."[1]

No comments:

Post a Comment